If you could turn a Straight into Gay, who would he be?

[JoelR]

Image ... with a blink of an eye, you can turn any straight guy into a gay guy!

Who would he be?  

An actor?

A friend?

A coworker?

A celebrity?  

 

Mine would be Chris Evans (movie actor in Captain America).  He's so dreamy, and yet he comes across as such a nice and approachable guy that you could take home to meet the parents.  

 

[wolfe]

A friend I fell in love with back when I was a teenager

[Nicolas]

4 hours ago, wolfe said:

A friend I fell in love with back when I was a teenager

A movie star, Jake Gyllenhaal, in brokeback mountain.... 

[JoelR]

7 hours ago, wolfe said:

A friend I fell in love with back when I was a teenager

Aww, teenage love .  Tell us more about him, how you met, and if you ever had any opportunity to express your feelings to him.

2 hours ago, Nicolas said:

A movie star, Jake Gyllenhaal, in brokeback mountain.... 

You aren't the only Brokeback Mountain superfan on our website, so you're in good company!

[wolfe]

I fell in love with him at church camp.we were in the 7th grade and the same cabin. He had light brown curly hair,a gorgeous smile and always laughing.Every year I hoped we would be in the same cabin but never were untill being in the grad cabin. By then he had grown into a tall muscular jock but it was always his smile that got me. The next year we were co consolers and one night we were outside the cabin talking and I so wanted to just kiss him but was afraid to.I think I came pretty close but then I didn't want a scandal to happen in all places.

        To make a long story short I came out to him five years ago and basically told him how I had felt all these years about him. He was really understanding and said why didn't you tell me sooner and that I had always been a good friend and would do anything for me. I really have a gut feeling he is also gay but he can't admit it. He dosent stay around and talk when he's in town and pops up at events. Almost like he's afraid he might have to open up. He had a high profile running NASCAR so that may be why. I personally told him how great he was and that he needed to find someone to share his life with.

        I will always carry a torch for him untill the day I die.I have never met any man who has come close to him in all aspects.He is the only one who felt like a soul mate. 

[JoelR]

@wolfe What a beautiful and romantic story !  Made me want to tear up inside 

 

[JackFTwist]

Whew, tough one.  First choice(s):  Any one of my three best friends from my senior year in high school.  Unlike @wolfe I don’t still carry torches for any of them, but at the time, my crushes were pretty serious. 

Out of contemporary guys, if we’re shooting for the moon:  Chris Evans and Jake Gyllenhaal would definitely be high on my list, along with Ryan Reynolds.  Other dreamy celebs:  Henry Caville (Superman, “The Immortals,” HBO’s “The Tudors” — for my money, the most handsome of all contemporary actors), Jamie Dornan, Armie Hammer, and of course, Matt Damon.  

But as long as we’re dreaming, my #1 and #2 picks overall:  classic Colt models John Pruitt (#1-4 below) and Doug Perry (#5-6).

          

[Steve]

I'd have to go with my favorite tennis star Andy Roddick.  In consideration would be  Jake Gyllenhaal  @JackFTwist  @Nicolas and I might have to share him.  Also actor Zac Efron.   Too bad we can't post photos of our choices.   

 

 

Edited February 4, 2017 by Steve

[wolfe]

On 2/3/2017 at 1:47 PM, wolfe said:

I fell in love with him at church camp.we were in the 7th grade and the same cabin. He had light brown curly hair,a gorgeous smile and always laughing.Every year I hoped we would be in the same cabin but never were untill being in the grad cabin. By then he had grown into a tall muscular jock but it was always his smile that got me. The next year we were co consolers and one night we were outside the cabin talking and I so wanted to just kiss him but was afraid to.I think I came pretty close but then I didn't want a scandal to happen in all places.

        To make a long story short I came out to him five years ago and basically told him how I had felt all these years about him. He was really understanding and said why didn't you tell me sooner and that I had always been a good friend and would do anything for me. I really have a gut feeling he is also gay but he can't admit it. He dosent stay around and talk when he's in town and pops up at events. Almost like he's afraid he might have to open up. He had a high profile running NASCAR so that may be why. I personally told him how great he was and that he needed to find someone to share his life with.

        I will always carry a torch for him untill the day I die.I have never met any man who has come close to him in all aspects.He is the only one who felt like a soul mate. 

I had a crush on Joseph Bottoms after I saw him in the Dove probably because he looked a lot like my friend. I would post photos of Bottoms but I don't know if that's ok anymore.

[tbill]

He would be George, a classmate of mine since the 2nd grade.  He blossomed into a very handsome guy with black hair and dreamy brown eyes with a gorgeous smile and personality to match. In 8th grade, we had P. E. together, and I always looked forward to showering with him after class just so I could check out his perfect ass and beautiful semi-erect penis!  Needless to say, he was the subject of many masterbation fantasies.  Unfortunately, I never got up the nerve to tell him how hot he made me.  I guess that's one of my big regrets in life.  I lost contact with George after high school. 

[tbill]

OK, there was also David, my older brother's best friend from high school. When I was in my mid to late teens, he came over ALL the time. He was very cute and also had beautiful, friendly eyes and a great smile. But what turned me on the most about David was he would always wear this really short pair of white cutoff jeans that enhanced his perfect ass rather nicely. (We're talking 1980s when shorts were much shorter than now.) He always wore them with one of his white, sleeveless half T-shirts (he had a collection of them) which showcased his awesome abs and midsection and never obstructed that perfect erection-making rear view of his.

Like George, David too was the subject of many right-handed fantasies. He wore that short and shirt combo at least three out of every four times he came over, if not more. I guess it must have been his favorite outfit. Little did David know it was my favorite, too!

Edited April 11, 2017 by tbill

[wolfe]

49 minutes ago, tbill said:

OK, there was also David, my older brother's best friend from high school. When I was in my mid to late teens, he came over ALL the time. He was very cute and also had beautiful, friendly eyes and a great smile. But what turned me on the most about David was he would always wear this really short pair of white cutoff jeans that enhanced his perfect ass rather nicely. (We're talking 1980s when shorts were much shorter than now.) He always wore them with one of his white, sleeveless half T-shirts (he had a collection of them) which showcased his awesome abs and midsection and never obstructed that perfect erection-making rear view of his.

Like George, David too was the subject of many right-handed fantasies. He wore that short and shirt combo at least three out of every four times he came over, if not more. I guess it must have been his favorite outfit. Little did David know it was my favorite, too!

Maybe you're why he wore it  

Edited April 11, 2017 by wolfe

[tbill]

OK, Wolfe! Now you've gone and gotten me incredibly horny with THAT suggestion! I haven't gotten off to that fantasy in years, and now you've added a fascinating angle to it that's getting me really overheated!

I think you've given me my next story....

[JoelR]

I think you're giving us all a nice image to think about.  Guys don't wear cutoff jeans like that anymore. 

[tbill]

Yeah, I don't recall them really being all that frayed. Maybe since they were white, they really didn't seem all that frayed. Dunno. But that's not what stood out to me....obviously. My eyes were focused more on his wonderful ass than how frayed his shorts may or may not have been.

But you're right, Joel. Guys dont wear cutoffs anymore. That was a 70s and early 80s thing.

[wolfe]

1 hour ago, tbill said:

Yeah, I don't recall them really being all that frayed. Maybe since they were white, they really didn't seem all that frayed. Dunno. But that's not what stood out to me....obviously. My eyes were focused more on his wonderful ass than how frayed his shorts may or may not have been.

But you're right, Joel. Guys dont wear cutoffs anymore. That was a 70s and early 80s thing.

Yes my neighbor who was five years older,ran around in just cut offs nothing else. I couldn't keep my eyes off him.